A non-renewal notice just landed. Here is your 60-day plan
Why your phone is ringing
State Farm General announced in 2024 that it would not renew roughly 72,000 California policies. About 30,000 were homeowners policies and about 42,000 were apartment or commercial. Divide it out and homeowners were roughly 42 percent of the total, so the notice reached well beyond single-family clients. When standard carriers step back, the state-backed insurer of last resort absorbs many of those risks. The California FAIR Plan reported exposure above $450 billion in 2024. In Florida, Citizens Property Insurance peaked at roughly 1.4 million policies in 2023, according to its policy count reports. None of these figures is a forecast for your book. They explain why your phone rings and why a non-renewal is now a routine event rather than a rare failure. The takeaway for this issue is simple: treat every non-renewal as a short project with a start date, a hard deadline, and a paper trail, and run it the same way every time.
Read the notice before you call
Before you dial, read the notice itself. Clients will say the company dropped them, but the letter tells you what actually happened, and the difference matters. Look for three items: whether it is a non-renewal at expiration or a mid-term cancellation, the stated effective date, and the reason given, if any. Notice periods and required wording are set by each state, so confirm the rule in your state's insurance code or with your department of insurance rather than relying on memory. Then check the date the notice was mailed against the effective date. If the notice appears late or defective, the policy may have to stay in force longer, and that is a question for the carrier's underwriting contact in writing. Also pull the client's file: dwelling limit, mortgagee name, loan number, and any open claims. You want every fact in front of you before the client asks you a single question.
What to say on the call
Keep the call short and in this order. Start with the fact: the carrier has decided not to renew the policy effective on a stated date, and read the reason in the notice if one is given. Then give the plan: you will request quotes from admitted carriers, then surplus lines carriers if needed, and the state insurer of last resort if neither works. Then give the client a task, such as sending photos of the roof and a list of recent updates. Do not promise a replacement, a price, or equal coverage. Say what you know, what you do not, and when you will call back, then call back on that day even if you have nothing new. Warn them that a policy from the California FAIR Plan or Citizens may cover less than the current one, so you will compare what each includes before anyone decides. Confirm everything you said in an email the same day.
A worked example: running the clock
Here is an illustration with invented numbers. Suppose you write 120 homeowners policies and one carrier non-renews 18 of them. That is 15 percent of the book. Assume, for this example only, that your state gives 60 days of notice before expiration; check your actual rule. Call the day the notice arrives day 0. At five calls a day, all 18 clients are reached by day 4. Submit applications to other carriers by day 14. Set a decision date of day 40: if no standard offer exists by then, file with the state insurer of last resort, which still leaves 20 days before expiration. Aim to have coverage bound by day 50, leaving 10 days to send proof of insurance to each mortgage lender. The point is not these exact dates. It is that you pick the dates on day 0, write them in each client file, and the buffer is built in rather than hoped for.
What people get wrong
The costly mistakes are small and repeated. First, waiting for the client to call back about quotes; silence is not a decision, and the expiration date does not move. Second, treating the state insurer of last resort as a first choice instead of a fallback after you have tried the standard and surplus markets, because the plan may cover less and cost differently. Third, comparing premiums alone. Two quotes with different deductibles, wind or hail exclusions, or dwelling limits are not the same product, so line them up on the same terms. Fourth, forgetting the mortgage lender. If the lender gets no proof of new coverage, it can buy force-placed insurance and bill the client, which typically protects the lender rather than the client. Fifth, letting a verbal conversation stand in for a record. If a client later says you never told them about the gap, an email is your answer, and its absence is your problem.
How to document it
Build one file per non-renewal and keep it boring. Save the notice with its postmark or delivery date. Log each call with date, time, who you spoke to, and what was said. Send a short confirming email after every call and keep the sent copy. Record every carrier you approached, the date you submitted, the response, and the reason for any decline. Keep the quotes you presented side by side, with deductibles and limits, and note which option the client chose and when. If the client declines to act or chooses a cheaper, thinner policy, get that in writing, even if it is just a reply to your email saying understood. Close the file with proof of new coverage and proof sent to the mortgagee. This costs little time per client, and it is the same record your errors and omissions carrier will expect if a dispute ever starts.
How to check your own book this week
Check your own book this week with four pulls. First, run a report of homeowners policies by carrier and expiration date, sorted by carrier, so you can see how concentrated you are. If one carrier holds a large share of your homeowners business, that is your exposure. Second, read each carrier's latest producer bulletins and your state department of insurance announcements for non-renewal news or appointment changes. Third, find your state's insurer of last resort, which is the California FAIR Plan in California and Citizens in Florida, and learn how an agent submits an application before you need to. Fourth, confirm each file holds a current mortgagee, email address, and mobile number, because a calling plan fails on bad contact data. Then take one next step alone: pick your largest carrier and write down the exact steps you would follow if it sent a notice on your biggest block tomorrow.
Fresh, consent-based leads in the states and products you write. Pick a pack, get routed leads delivered to your agency, and start working them the same day.
Get more leads for your agency
Buy a lead pack and get routed, consent-based leads in the states and products you write.
General educational information for licensed agents, not legal or compliance advice. Notice periods, required wording, and insurer-of-last-resort rules vary by state; confirm them with your state department of insurance and your agency's compliance resources. The 120-policy book, 18 non-renewals, and 60-day notice period are illustrations only. Figures on State Farm General, the California FAIR Plan, and Citizens come from the California Department of Insurance and California FAIR Plan public reports and Florida Citizens policy count reports.